London, England — Sony has beaten the biggest consumer claim ever brought over PlayStation Store pricing. On Tuesday, November 17, 2026, London's Competition Appeal Tribunal dismissed the claim in its entirety, ruling the case brought for about 12.2 million UK PlayStation users had not established that Sony broke competition law.

The claim, brought by consumer campaigner Alex Neill's Alex Neill Class Representative Limited, sought £1.49 billion in damages, rising to £1.971 billion with interest — the almost £2 billion (about $2.6 billion) figure in the headlines. It covered UK consumers who bought digital PlayStation games or add-on content between August 2016 and February 2026, and was funded by Woodsford with Milberg London acting for the class.

The allegation was that Sony abused a dominant position by requiring digital games and add-ons to be bought and sold only through its own PlayStation Store. The claimants said Sony's restrictions amounted to exclusive dealing, tying and a refusal to supply rival stores, and that the closed store let Sony charge excessive and unfair prices — arguing prices would have been about 20 percent lower without the alleged abuses. Sony generally targets a margin of about 30 percent on digital sales.

The tribunal, chaired by Ben Tidswell with Lord Richardson and Derek Ridyard, rejected the foundation of that case. In its judgment, [2026] CAT 86, it called the claimants' proposed market — digital PlayStation games and add-ons alone — an "unsafe" basis on which to assess Sony's conduct. Physical games, multi-homing and cross-platform play all constrained Sony, and console buyers weigh game prices when choosing a machine, which disciplines what Sony can charge afterwards. On that systems-market frame, Sony's dominance had not been established.

The other allegations failed too. The claimants' economic counterfactual was not credible and the 20-percent-lower figure was not made out. Opening PlayStation to a third-party store would require significant adaptation at significant cost, with likely reduced security, so the strict Bronner test for forcing access applied and was not met. On pricing, the margin was not established as excessive — or unfair even if it was.

The claim was filed in August 2022, certified in November 2023, and heard over a 30-day trial between March and May 2026. It was the third claim against a major tech company to reach trial in Britain since the start of 2025, after the tribunal ruled against Apple over its App Store last year — a decision Apple is seeking to appeal — and a Qualcomm case withdrawn after trial. A trial of a lawsuit against Google began in October.

Both sides reacted on the record. Stephanie Burns, Senior Vice President and General Counsel at Sony Interactive Entertainment, said the ruling affirms the company's business model; Sony had argued it had "invested years and billions" in its platform and rival stores would free-ride on that investment. Neill said she was "disappointed," adding: "This case has been five years in the making and raised important questions on behalf of 12 million UK consumers." Her team is considering whether to appeal, and no compensation has been awarded. Costs and permission to appeal will be dealt with at a hearing in the week beginning December 14, 2026.

Why it matters: this is a clean win for the closed-store model the whole console industry runs on — competition between gaming systems, not inside one system's store, is the test that counts, a ruling that now frames every similar fight against the other platform owners.