YNW Melly's defence team has asked a Broward County judge to keep gang-related evidence and gang expert testimony out of his double-murder retrial, in an eight-page motion in limine filed on November 13, 2026 and reported on November 17. The filing, brought by attorneys Carey Haughwout and Drew Findling, argues that the gang evidence presented at the rapper's first trial never connected to the killings he is charged with — and that letting a second jury hear it would invite verdicts built on stereotype rather than proof. No ruling on the motion has been reported.
Melly, whose legal name is Jamell Demons, faces two counts of first-degree murder in the October 26, 2018 deaths of Anthony Williams, known as YNW Sakchaser, and Christopher Thomas Jr., known as YNW Juvy — his childhood friends and fellow members of the YNW collective. Prosecutors allege the two men were shot inside a vehicle and that the scene was staged to look like a drive-by shooting. Those are allegations, not findings: Melly has pleaded not guilty, he has not been convicted of the killings, and his first trial ended without a verdict.
WHAT THE MOTION ASKS
The motion takes aim at the gang testimony the State presented the first time around, in particular the evidence of a detective identified in the filing as Detective Polo, who testified about the Bloods and the G-Shine set — their origins, rules and hierarchy — and interpreted photographs, conversations and symbols for the jury. "The gang-related evidence at the first trial was lengthy, prejudicial, and, most importantly, bore no connection to the alleged murders," the defence wrote. "However, at no point did Detective Polo connect the gang-related evidence to the allegations in this case."
The indictment includes an allegation that the killings benefited, promoted or furthered a criminal gang. The defence argues that allegation cannot justify broad testimony about gang culture untied to the charged shootings, and warns that sweeping descriptions of gang practices risk encouraging jurors to judge Melly through stereotypes. The filing also leans on an earlier ruling in the case: according to the defence, Judge John Murphy's December 20, 2023 order already excluded most gang-related digital material, including emails, text messages and expert interpretations of those records.
THE OTHER SIDE
Prosecutors have argued in this case that gang evidence helps explain motive and intent. The new filing quotes the State's response to an earlier defence motion as calling the evidence "directly relevant to the State's theory of the case regarding motive and intent, regardless of potential sentence." That is the State's position on the earlier motion, reproduced inside the new filing; no prosecution response to the November 13 motion itself was reported, and the court has not been reported to rule on the request. Pretrial evidentiary hearings are scheduled for later this month — Law&Crime's trial coverage lists full-day sessions on November 20, 23 and 24, 2026 addressing search warrants and the admissibility of rap lyrics and gang evidence — which is where a fight of this kind would ordinarily be decided.
HOW THE CASE GOT HERE
Demons was arrested in February 2019 and has remained in custody since. His first trial began in June 2023 in Fort Lauderdale, and on July 22, 2023 Judge Murphy declared a mistrial after the jury deadlocked following three days of deliberations, the Associated Press reported at the time. Broward County prosecutors, who are seeking the death penalty if he is convicted, moved to retry the case. The retrial then spent years in evidentiary disputes and appeals — including the December 2023 suppression order the new motion relies on — before landing on its current date.
Jury selection for the retrial is scheduled to begin on January 6, 2027 in Broward County, with Judge Martin S. Fein presiding. Under Fein's October 13, 2026 order, 500 prospective jurors will be summoned and screened in groups of 50, juror information will stay confidential, and the public will watch selection by livestream rather than from courtroom seats. Findling, who joined the defence in 2025, leads the team alongside Haughwout.
WHY IT MATTERS
Evidence fights decide what story a jury is allowed to hear, and in this case the gap between the two sides is the whole trial in miniature. If the motion succeeds, prosecutors lose the gang framework they say supplies motive and intent, and must prove the shootings on the facts of one night in October 2018. If it fails, the defence must overcome exactly the prejudice it describes — a jury walked through gang origins, rules and symbols before it weighs the charged conduct. Either ruling lands in a capital case where the defendant will have spent nearly eight years in custody, without a conviction, by the time the first juror is seated.
Sources: Defence Motion in Limine to Exclude Gang Evidence and Gang Expert Testimony, filed November 13, 2026, as reported and quoted by AllHipHop (November 17, 2026); Associated Press reporting on the July 22, 2023 mistrial; Judge Martin S. Fein's October 13, 2026 jury-selection order as reported from Broward County Clerk filings. All charges are allegations; YNW Melly has pleaded not guilty.
