Fort Lauderdale, Florida — YNW Melly's lawyers have asked a Broward County judge to keep his own music out of his double-murder retrial. In a motion in limine filed on November 10, 2026, defence attorney Carey Haughwout asked Judge Martin S. Fein to exclude all rap lyrics and music videos from the case — 58 songs that prosecutors have identified — arguing the music has no evidentiary value and would unfairly prejudice the jury that decides whether Jamell Demons lives with a conviction or walks into a second hung jury. Judge Fein has not ruled on the motion.

Melly faces two counts of first-degree murder in the October 26, 2018 deaths of Anthony Williams, known as YNW Sakchaser, and Christopher Thomas Jr., known as YNW Juvy — his childhood friends and fellow members of the YNW collective. Prosecutors allege the two men were shot inside a vehicle and that the scene was staged to look like a drive-by shooting. Those are allegations, not findings: Melly has pleaded not guilty, he has never been convicted in the case, and his first trial ended in a mistrial in July 2023 after the jury deadlocked. He has been in custody since 2019.

WHAT THE MOTION ARGUES

The filing's core claim is that rap is being read as autobiography in a way no other genre is. "The perception of rap music as a true reflection or autobiographical narration of the performer is uniquely rooted in deep societal biases," the motion reads. "Rap music is many things, but it is not reliable evidence. Not one song on that list is relevant evidence that should be admitted by this Court at trial."

The defence backs the argument with an empirical study conducted by Florida Atlantic University with 523 potential Florida jurors, which the motion says found that exposure to Melly's lyrics produced significantly more negative perceptions of him. It also singles out "Murder on My Mind," his best-known song: the track first appeared on SoundCloud in March 2017 and was released as a single on June 1, 2018 — months before the October 2018 shootings — and the defence argues its first-person narrative is fiction that jurors could wrongly mistake for an admission. Most of the 58 songs, the defence says, traffic in common rap tropes about money, cars and violence without describing the specific events of 2018, and prosecutors have not established a motive connecting the lyrics to the shootings.

THE OTHER SIDE

Prosecutors have previously indicated that some lyrics could speak to motive or intent, and the State is not letting the defence's evidence bids pass unchallenged. A prosecution filing on November 18 set out the matters the State plans to argue at this month's pretrial hearings, including its challenges to the defence's attempts to exclude rap evidence — and to a separate November 13 defence motion asking the court to keep gang evidence and gang-expert testimony out of the retrial, a request BIA808 covered when it was filed. Hearings on the pending motions are scheduled for November 20 and November 23, with the State's filing also listing November 24. No ruling on the lyrics motion has been reported, and nothing in this story states one.

HOW THE CASE GOT HERE

Demons was arrested in February 2019. His first trial ended on July 22, 2023, when a mistrial was declared after the jury could not reach a verdict. Prosecutors elected to retry the case, and after years of evidentiary disputes the retrial is now scheduled to begin with jury selection on January 6, 2027, in Broward County, with Judge Fein presiding. The lyrics fight is one of several that will decide what that jury is allowed to hear: the gang-evidence motion is pending alongside it, and prosecutors have also moved against the defence's alibi notice and witness list.

WHY IT MATTERS

This is the "rap on trial" debate at its highest stakes. If the motion succeeds, the State must prove the shootings on the facts of one night in October 2018, without the soundtrack it says explains motive. If it fails, jurors will hear the defendant's own songs — including one released before the killings — and the defence must overcome exactly the prejudice its filing describes, in a case where the defendant will have spent nearly eight years in custody without a conviction by the time the first juror is seated. Judge Fein's ruling, expected out of this month's hearings, will be one of the most consequential pretrial decisions in the case.

Photo: YNW Melly in his 2019 Broward County mugshot (file photo).

Sources: Defence motion in limine filed November 10, 2026 in Broward County, as reported and quoted by HipHopHero (November 19, 2026, reporting Bryson "Boom" Paul's read of the filing) and HypeFresh (November 19, 2026); the State's November 18, 2026 filing agenda as reported by ItsBizKit / AllHipHop (November 19, 2026). All charges are allegations; YNW Melly has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.