Jonathan Taylor is staying in Indianapolis. The Colts did not trade their star running back before Tuesday's 4:00 p.m. ET NFL trade deadline, ending weeks of speculation with the deadline's biggest non-move.
The verdict landed about an hour before the deadline. NFL insiders Tom Pelissero and Jordan Schultz both reported that Taylor would not be going anywhere, because Indianapolis never received the kind of offer it was holding out for. "Multiple teams offered a second-round pick and more for Taylor," Pelissero reported. "But the Colts wanted a blockbuster offer to even consider it. Instead, Taylor stays in Indy."
That asking price was set early and never moved. Ian Rapoport reported the Colts wanted a package similar to what the San Francisco 49ers sent the Carolina Panthers for Christian McCaffrey in 2022 — a haul built from second-, third-, fourth- and fifth-round picks. The best offers on the table never got there. The New York Giants made the one offer with a team and terms attached, a second- and a fifth-round pick reported by Jay Glazer on November 8, and pulled it before deadline day.
Taylor, 27, was the centerpiece of a Colts sell-off that moved almost everyone else. Indianapolis had already traded guard Quenton Nelson to Seattle and defensive tackle DeForest Buckner to San Francisco in late October, then sent wide receivers Josh Downs to Kansas City and Keenan Allen to San Francisco on deadline day itself. Quarterback Daniel Jones, the other name in the rumor mill, was also told he would not be traded. Through eight games this season Taylor had rushed 148 times for 610 yards and eight touchdowns for a Colts team with just two wins.
The contract explains the hard line. Taylor signed a two-year, $44 million extension in August and is under contract through 2028, so Indianapolis was never forced to sell low on a 27-year-old franchise back in his prime. With no team willing to meet the price, the Colts kept the one player their rebuild can be built around.
The debate now shifts to value. Suitors including Denver, Seattle, Green Bay and Minnesota were linked to Taylor at various points, and every one of them decided a second-round headline offer was the ceiling. Whether Indianapolis protected its best asset or missed its best window to cash in is the argument that will follow this team into the offseason, when the reporting suggests the Colts could entertain offers again.
What's next: Taylor finishes the season as Indianapolis' centerpiece, and the same teams that called this month are expected to call again when the new league year opens. The blockbuster price, presumably, travels with him.
Sources: Heavy; NBC Sports (Pro Football Talk); RotoWire; NFL Trade Rumors.
