Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith is back on top of the Heisman Trophy race, at least in the eyes of On3's voters.

On3 published its post-Week 11 Heisman Trophy Poll on Monday, November 16, 2026, and Smith leads it with 135 points, ahead of Miami quarterback Darian Mensah at 127 points, Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr at 92 points and Utah quarterback Devon Dampier at 71 points. The poll is a vote of On3's own panel (David Pollack and Brooks Austin did not vote this week), not the official Heisman ballot cast in December, but with two weeks left in the regular season it is a clear snapshot of the race.

Smith's case is production that survives the chaos around him. Even with starting quarterback Julian Sayin out and Luke Fahey in, Smith caught 11 passes for 117 yards and a touchdown in Ohio State's 28-19 win over Northwestern, breaking the Big Ten career receiving yards record in the process. It was his sixth 100-yard receiving game of the season and his seventh straight game with a touchdown, and it lifted his season line to 80 receptions for 1,317 yards and 15 touchdowns.

Mensah is the quarterback case, and it is built on efficiency for an unbeaten team. He completed 30 of 41 passes for 382 yards with one touchdown and no interceptions as Miami beat Duke 36-25 to stay undefeated. On the season he is completing 76.3 percent of his passes for 3,076 yards with 29 touchdowns against just two interceptions, plus two rushing scores.

Carr and Dampier round out the top four with very different profiles. Carr was solid rather than spectacular in Notre Dame's 41-7 win over Boston College, going 20-for-28 for 217 yards with two touchdowns and one interception, his first pick since September 26; he sits at 2,385 passing yards and 23 touchdowns through ten games. Dampier did a bit of everything as Utah stayed undefeated with a 40-39 win over Arizona: 13-for-25 for 204 yards, two touchdowns and an interception through the air, plus 14 carries for 100 yards and two more touchdowns on the ground.

The rest of the top 10: Duke running back Nate Sheppard is fifth at 69 points, Indiana receiver Charlie Becker and Tennessee running back DeSean Bishop are tied for sixth at 48, Oregon State receiver Jesse Legree is eighth at 43, Alabama quarterback Keelon Russell is ninth at 41 and Wake Forest quarterback Gio Lopez is tenth at 36.

The betting market mostly agrees with the poll, with one swap. BetMGM priced the race the same day with Smith as the -145 favourite, Mensah at +375, Dampier at +600 and Carr at +1200: the same top two, but with Dampier ahead of Carr, the reverse of the poll's third and fourth places.

Why it matters: the Heisman usually belongs to a quarterback on a playoff team, and three of the poll's top four fit that mould. Smith is asking voters to make an exception for a receiver who keeps producing no matter who throws him the ball, and with two weeks and a conference-championship weekend still to play, both the poll and the market say the exception is currently winning.

Sources: On3 Heisman Trophy Poll after Week 11 (on3.com, November 16, 2026); BetMGM Heisman Trophy odds (sports.betmgm.com, November 16, 2026).