Jeremiah Smith is back on top of the Heisman Trophy market — and he is doing it as a wide receiver, on a three-loss team, with his starting quarterback in the stands.

BoydsBets' cross-book board, updated Friday, November 13, 2026, prices the Ohio State receiver at +200 — the best price at Caesars, a 33.3 percent implied chance — across the four books it tracks: bet365, BetMGM, Caesars and FanDuel. Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr is second at +290 (best price at FanDuel, 25.6 percent implied), and Miami quarterback Darian Mensah is third at +300 (best price at BetMGM, 25.0 percent implied). Georgia quarterback Gunner Stockton, the name at the centre of the week's television framing, sits sixth on the same board at +2000. The prices are the books' prices, not a result — BoydsBets itself notes the board's implied percentages add to more than 100 percent, and that gap is the books' margin.

The prediction markets point the same way, a few days earlier. On3 reported on November 11 that Smith had re-emerged as the Polymarket favourite after Week 10 at 29 percent, ahead of Mensah at 27 percent and Carr at 21 percent, and Covers' November 11 Heisman page, using Kalshi prices, had Smith at 29 percent and Mensah at 28 percent, with Carr third. Two different market types, priced days apart, land on the same name at the top.

The context is what makes the price remarkable. Ohio State is 6-3 and ranked No. 20 in the College Football Playoff rankings after a 41-28 home loss to Oregon, and the Buckeyes have lost two straight. Starting quarterback Julian Sayin will miss his third straight game on Saturday after fracturing his right elbow against Indiana on October 17 — he is listed as out on Ohio State's availability report for the Northwestern game, and freshman Luke Fahey will make his third career start. In other words, the market's favourite is a receiver whose quarterback is a freshman backup, on a team playing to keep its season alive.

Saturday is the next test, for Smith and for the price. Ohio State hosts Northwestern at Ohio Stadium in Columbus, Ohio, on Saturday, November 14, 2026, with kickoff at 12:00 p.m. ET. Northwestern will also be without its starting quarterback, Aidan Chiles, who misses his second straight game. Later the same afternoon, No. 22 Missouri plays at No. 1 Georgia at 3:30 p.m. ET — the window in which Stockton, at +2000, would have to start closing a very large gap.

Why it matters: the Heisman is a quarterback's award in most years, and the last receiver to win it did so in a season that bent every normal rule. Smith's case, as the markets are pricing it, does not run through a dominant team or a star quarterback — it runs through being, week after week, the most dangerous player on the field anyway. One more Saturday like that, and +200 will look generous. One quiet afternoon in Columbus, and the quarterbacks behind him are close enough to take the top spot back.