Columbus, Ohio — There is no consensus Heisman frontrunner in the media polls — there are three of them, depending on which poll you read. That is the finding of Heisman.com's latest buzz roundup, published Tuesday, November 17, 2026 by the Heisman Trust's own site.
Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith leads two of the boards. He tops The Athletic's staff poll with 22 of 25 first-place votes — second-place Darian Mensah took two, and the final vote went elsewhere — and he also leads On3's polling, where On3's own post-Week 11 poll scores him at 135 points. Smith's case starts with Saturday's line against Northwestern: 11 catches for 117 yards and a touchdown.
But Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr tops two other boards — Yahoo Sports and Sports Illustrated. Carr helped Notre Dame follow its upset of then-No. 1 Miami with a win over Boston College in which he threw for 217 yards and two scores, per Heisman.com's roundup.
And Miami quarterback Darian Mensah leads Bleacher Report's rankings. Mensah guided 9-1 Miami past his old team, Duke, on Saturday with 382 passing yards and a score — a storyline no other candidate in the field can match.
The rest of the live field, per the roundup: Utah quarterback Devon Dampier, Miami receiver Malachi Toney, and a fan-vote race in which Bishop currently leads the Heisman Hopefuls fan vote under its season-long weighted model, with Smith second and Toney third. Former Heisman winner Robert Griffin III's latest top five runs Smith, Mensah, Dampier, Carr and Bishop.
These are media polls and rankings, not betting odds and not ballots. The actual Heisman ballots are due at 5:00 p.m. ET on December 7, and the winner is announced December 12 — which means every candidate has two more weeks of regular-season football to move a race that, right now, three different rooms are scoring three different ways.
Why it matters: Smith leading on points while Carr and Mensah lead elsewhere is exactly what a split electorate looks like before the final weekends. The receiver has the strongest single poll number in the field — 22 of 25 first-place votes is a landslide inside one room — but a Heisman is won across all the rooms, and November's last two Saturdays are where split races usually break.
