A perfect score was not enough to save Harry Shum Jr. Dancing With the Stars ended its Season 35 semifinals on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, with the night's most shocking result of the season: Shum and his partner Jenna Johnson were eliminated on ABC, one week before the finale, despite earning a perfect 60 out of 60 from the judges — a total matched only by Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov.
The elimination came at the end of a two-hour live broadcast in which six couples each performed two dances they had not performed before, one ballroom and one Latin, for judges Carrie Ann Inaba, Derek Hough and Bruno Tonioli. The result was decided, as it is every week, by the lowest combination of judges' scores and viewer votes — and on this night the vote overruled the leaderboard completely.
The reveal built the tension deliberately. The teams were called safe in this order: Connor Wood and Rylee Arnold first, then Glenn and Pashkov, Tatyana Ali and Jan Ravnik, and Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas. That left two couples standing at the end — Shum and Johnson, and Ezra Frech and Daniella Karagach. TV Insider's recap noted the last two standing were not necessarily the bottom two in the combined standings, which made what came next land harder: Frech and Karagach were called safe, and Shum and Johnson were sent home.
Nothing about the dancing explained it. Shum and Johnson opened with a paso doble to "We Found Love" by Rihanna featuring Calvin Harris that Inaba called the paso doble of the season, earning three 10s for a perfect 30 out of 30. They returned with a quickstep to "Valerie" by Mark Ronson featuring Amy Winehouse that Tonioli called impeccable at every level, earning a second straight perfect 30 and a confirmed 60 out of 60 for the night. Hough had told Shum the quickstep was how you dance your way into the finals. The judges were right about the dancing. It still was not enough.
The rest of the leaderboard shows how strange the math became. Glenn and Pashkov matched the perfect night, adding a Viennese waltz to "Dangerous Woman" by Ariana Grande for their own 60 out of 60. Higgins and Ballas finished on 59, pairing their first-round perfect samba with a 29 for a Viennese waltz to "Shrike" by Hozier. Frech and Karagach scored 57, capped by a jive to "Footloose" by Kenny Loggins that earned the couple their first perfect score of the season. Ali and Ravnik finished on 55. And Wood and Arnold sat at the very bottom of the judges' leaderboard on 48 out of 60 — yet they were the first couple called safe. TV Insider's analysis of the result noted that, under the show's system of combining scores and votes, Wood's survival from the bottom of the leaderboard points to an exceptionally strong viewer vote, although no official vote totals are published.
The context makes the exit sting more. Shum and Johnson arrived at the semifinals as the couple to beat after topping last week's Grammy Night leaderboard, and Shum — an actor and trained dancer — had been a frontrunner since the premiere. Last week proved the same lesson in reverse, when Jenna Dewan and Val Chmerkovskiy were eliminated despite a strong score. The semifinals simply proved it at the highest possible level: on this show, a perfect night from the judges is only half the result.
Five couples now go into the Season 35 finale on Tuesday, November 24 at 8/7c on ABC and Disney+: Glenn and Pashkov, Higgins and Ballas, Frech and Karagach, Ali and Ravnik, and Wood and Arnold. They will compete for the Len Goodman Mirrorball Trophy in the season's closing episode.
Why it matters: this is the result the whole format quietly promises and rarely delivers so cleanly. A couple did everything the judges asked, at the highest standard the judges can award, and went home anyway — because the audience half of the scoreboard said otherwise. Whatever happens in the finale, the semifinals made the season's real rule impossible to miss: on Dancing With the Stars, perfection gets you to the reveal. It does not get you through it.
Sources: TV Insider semifinals recap and results analysis, November 17, 2026; Parade semifinals recap, November 17, 2026; Sports Illustrated semifinals live recap, November 17, 2026; The Wrap semifinals recap, November 17, 2026.
