Fiona Harvey's defamation lawsuit against Netflix over Baby Reindeer will go before a jury in Los Angeles on Tuesday, May 18, 2027, after U.S. District Judge R. Gary Klausner set the trial date and turned down a joint request from both sides to hear the case on July 27, 2027 instead.
Harvey's U.S. lawyer, Richard Roth, said his client was "elated" when the date arrived. "We've just learned that the trial of Fiona Harvey versus Netflix is going to be on May 18, 2027. We just got the notice, like within the last hour," Roth said. "Both sides submitted a document which provided for more time, but the judge said, 'No, you're trying this in May.' I'm excited about this case. I think this case has been sitting for too long."
The case turns on claims, not findings — nothing in Harvey's suit has been proven, and a jury has never weighed it. Harvey, a Scottish former lawyer, says she is the inspiration for Martha Scott, the stalker played by Jessica Gunning in the series. In her suit she claims the programme falsely portrayed her as a twice-convicted stalker who was sentenced to five years in prison, and as a woman who sexually assaulted the show's creator, Richard Gadd. She says she has never been convicted of stalking, and her legal team has called the line that opens the series — "This is a true story" — "the biggest lie in television history." Roth said Harvey has faced "terrible mental anguish since April of 2024" and that "it took two and a half years to get a trial date and three years to be heard in court."
Netflix's side is the opposite. In court papers the company has said what was shown on screen was substantially true, argues Harvey has not identified a single provably false statement of fact about her, and says her reputation had already been harmed by earlier reports. When the lawsuit was filed, Netflix said it would "defend this matter vigorously" and support Gadd's right to tell his story. Gadd, who is not a defendant in the case, said in a 2024 court statement: "Martha Scott is not Fiona Harvey." He has described the series as emotionally true. Netflix has not commented publicly on the new trial date.
The road to that date runs through almost the whole life of the show. Baby Reindeer — seven episodes created by and starring Gadd as Donny Dunn, a barman and struggling comedian, and adapted from his 2019 Edinburgh Fringe one-man play — was released on April 11, 2024, and has been viewed more than 100 million times, winning six Emmy Awards including Outstanding Limited Series. Within days of its release, viewers used clues in the programme to identify Harvey online, and she spoke publicly to the Daily Record in April 2024, saying Martha was based on her. She filed her lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California on June 6, 2024.
In September 2024, Judge Klausner refused to strike her core defamation claim under California's anti-SLAPP law, writing that there is a major difference between stalking and being convicted of stalking in a court of law, and that the series appears to present itself as fact rather than as Gadd's interpretation — while dismissing parts of her other claims. A trial was first set for May 6, 2025, but Netflix appealed the anti-SLAPP ruling and the case froze. In October 2026 the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit questioned whether it even had jurisdiction over that appeal, Netflix withdrew it, and the appeal was dismissed on procedural grounds — the appeals court did not rule on whether Harvey was defamed, and Netflix can still challenge the anti-SLAPP ruling after a final judgment. On November 3, 2026, Harvey filed a First Amended Complaint narrowing her case to three claims — defamation, intentional infliction of emotional distress and violation of her right of publicity — and demanding a jury trial. The May 2027 date followed less than two weeks later, with discovery to be completed by February, according to C21Media's reporting of the scheduling.
The money at stake depends on which filing you read. The amended complaint seeks more than $50 million in actual damages, more than $50 million in compensatory damages including mental anguish and lost business, and more than $50 million in profits from the series, plus punitive damages, legal fees and interest — the three main buckets alone total more than $150 million, and the latest trial-date reporting puts the full demand at more than $170 million including punitive damages, the same total the original 2024 complaint reached with a $20 million punitive demand on top of the three $50 million claims.
Why it matters: this is the test case for the "true story" label in the streaming era. Klausner let the claim through in 2024 precisely because the series presents itself as fact, so the trial will ask a Los Angeles jury to draw the line between dramatising a real ordeal and defaming an identifiable living person — a line every streamer, studio and creator working from real events is watching. What happens next is mechanical: discovery closes in February, and on May 18, 2027, Harvey's claims and Netflix's defence finally go in front of the jury that will decide them.
Sources: Glasgow Times, November 14, 2026 (trial date, Judge Klausner's rejection of the joint July 27, 2027 request, Richard Roth quotes, Netflix's court-papers position); C21Media reporting carried in the Further & Better industry roundup, November 17, 2026 (trial date independently confirmed; discovery to be completed by February); First Amended Complaint, Harvey v. Netflix, Case No. 2:24-cv-04744-RGK-AJR (U.S. District Court, Central District of California, filed November 3, 2026); Judge Klausner's order of September 27, 2024; TheWrap, November 2026 (amended complaint and damages breakdown); Reuters reporting of the original June 2024 filing (damages demands and Netflix's statement).
